Home / Space force / ‘Star Trek: Short Treks’ Review: Did Spock Just Laugh in ‘Q&A’?

‘Star Trek: Short Treks’ Review: Did Spock Just Laugh in ‘Q&A’?

Spread the love

Indications are that spoilers lie forward.

Except for the recent “Star Trek” trailers that dropped at New York Comedian Con, it’s been about seven months since our final “Trek” repair, when the considerably disappointing Season 2 finale of “Star Trek Discovery” aired. 

Nonetheless, as was introduced on the “Star Trek Universe” panel by showrunner Alex Kurtzman, the primary of six new “Short Treks” is now accessible to stream on CBS All Entry. Entitled “Q&A,” it is set on board the usEnterprise simply as Ensign Spock (Ethan Peck) arrives for the very first time. 

Following a tweaked, snazzy-looking intro, we see Spock beaming from a really uncommon trying transporter room to a way more acquainted setting, the transporter room on the usEnterprise. 

We additionally see first officer Quantity One (Rebecca Romijn) trying over a PADD (Private Entry Show Gadget) with what seems to be her identify on it… Lt. Cmdr. Una. She welcomes Spock onto the usEnterprise and collectively they slowly stroll via the corridors of the ship.

Associated: Live Long and Prosper: Every Actor Who Played Spock on ‘Star Trek’
Extra: ‘Star Trek: Discovery’s’ Ethan Peck Talks About Filling Spock-Size Boots

It is Spock’s first day on the Enterprise with Quantity One within the “Star Trek: Quick Treks” episode “Q&A.”

(Picture credit score: CBS All Entry)

“You’ve got been on this ship precisely 37 seconds and you have not requested a single query. Not what I anticipate from a science officer,” Quantity One says. “I anticipate you to barrage each crewman you meet with questions, beginning with me, to the purpose that you simply develop into an annoyance. You’ve till we attain that turbolift, go,” she says.

“What’s your identify sir?” Spock asks. 

“Simply name me Quantity One,” she replies. 

Quantity One and Ensign Spock get to know one another by the use of being caught in a turbolift.

(Picture credit score: CBS All Entry)

Ever for the reason that inclusion of the Capt. Pike-era Enterprise in “Discovery” and the following return of the character Quantity One solely beforehand recognized from the “Star Trek: Unique Sequence” pilot “The Cage” and it’s repurposing in “The Menagerie” (S01, E11 and 12), followers previous and new have puzzled if she can be given a reputation on this new incarnation of “Star Trek.” It is at this level, sadly, we’re reminded of one of many bizarre, ideas of this new “Star Trek”collection: that there is by some means huge quantities of area between decks. Sufficient to really have employee drones in operation, which is absurd, actually. Each conceivable area can be stuffed, even on a starship, however as a substitute a experience in turbolift seems extra like a experience on Area Mountain.

The area between decks of the Enterprise is portrayed as being monumental; certainly area is at a premium, even on a starship.

(Picture credit score: CBS All Entry)

This minor grumble apart, the reimagined Enterprise does look attractive. 

Quantity One and Spock proceed their dialog, discussing varied scientific ideas till the turbolift breaks down. Naturally, if anybody has been unlucky sufficient to be on this place, it’s hoped that the short-term delay might be a brief one, however on this occasion it turns into clear that they’re going to be there for some time. 

The 2 appear to have some pure chemistry —  virtually an excessive amount of — the extent even that the notion of a relationship doesn’t really feel not possible. They’re capable of end one another’s sentences and share comparable opinions on many issues. 

Repeated makes an attempt to name Engineering show ineffective and so the Q&A session continues.

“What are the three most salient info about Captain Pike?” Spock asks.

Quantity One ponders for a second, then replies, “One, his capability for listening to out one other standpoint is exceed solely by his willingness to vary his personal as soon as he has heard you out. Two, regardless that he’s probably the most closely embellished preventing captain in Starfleet, he views resorting to pressure as an admission to failure. And three, he’s completely unsentimental. Besides in terms of horses.”

A while passes and we see the pair resigned to sitting on the ground. Quantity One makes an attempt to bypass something-or-other within the ceiling panel, however this solely ends in an unlucky brief circuit. She asks Spock if he was smiling as he transported aboard the Enterprise and tells him she discovered it barely disconcerting. 

What follows is a monologue of recommendation about “retaining your freaky to your self” and the struggles of getting to hide components of your character; for Spock clearly, that is his feelings. At this level, Quantity One … er, breaks into music. 

This scene feels a bit unusual and in reality this complete episode is just not the perfect instance of what Michael Chabon is able to writing. Lest we overlook the superb “Quick Trek” episode “Calypso.” Furthermore, Chabon received the 2001 Pulitzer Prize for Literature (fiction) for his novel “The Amazing Adventures of Kavalier & Clay” and wrote the vastly underrated “John Carter.” So, it is no shock he is been recruited as a full-time author for “Star Trek: Picard.”

It’s all the time good to see Spock having fun with himself.

(Picture credit score: CBS All Entry)

However “Q&A” feels contrived. Quantity One’s rendition of “I Am The Very Mannequin Of a Trendy Main Basic” from “The Pirates of Penzance” for instance her “freaky” to distinction towards Spock having to quell all his emotion … jars. Are we meant to just accept that Spock was snug displaying emotion proper up till he first stepped foot on the Enterprise? What occurred to all these years on the Vulcan Science Academy, his struggles when he was younger? And why weren’t Spock and Quantity One simply beamed out of the caught turbolift?

It is great to have some new “Trek” to have the ability to watch —  even whether it is only a few minutes —  and we’ve all the time preferred the manufacturing design on the reimagined Enterprise (other than all of the area between the decks), plus after all Ethan Peck and Rebecca Romijn had been good casting selections for his or her respective roles, however this primary “Quick Trek” nonetheless appears like a missed alternative to do one thing a bit extra attention-grabbing.

Observe Scott Snowden on Twitter. Observe us on Twitter @Spacedotcom and on Facebook.  

Source link

About Reanna

Future wars is what I am looking for with Space force.

Check Also

Virgin Orbit launches Space Force mission

Spread the love WASHINGTON — Virgin Orbit efficiently positioned a set of payloads for the …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.